Nigerian loses ₦430m compensation fight over 117 days in South African detention

A Nigerian man, Sunday Okoro, has suffered another legal setback in South Africa after an appeal court refused to reopen his ₦430m compensation case over spending 117 days in detention on suspicion of murder.

The Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed Okoro’s latest application, bringing another blow to his efforts to obtain damages from the country’s Minister of Police over his arrest and detention in 2002.

Okoro was arrested on July 3, 2002, after police discovered a man’s body hanging in the bathroom of an apartment he had reportedly rented in Durban.

The discovery prompted officers to suspect foul play, leading to his arrest and subsequent detention.

He was released on November 29, 2002, after prosecutors withdrew the murder charges against him.

Following his release, Okoro took the police minister to court, demanding R5.41m, estimated at about ₦430m, as compensation for his arrest, detention and the hardship he claimed to have suffered.

However, the KwaZulu-Natal High Court in Durban ruled that officers had reasonable grounds to suspect him of involvement in the death and dismissed his claim.

Determined to challenge the decision, the Nigerian sought permission to appeal at both the High Court and the Supreme Court of Appeal but was unsuccessful.

He subsequently approached the president of the appeal court for a review of the decision.

According to South African news platform IOL, a three-judge panel considered his application, with Acting Judge of Appeal Molitsoane and Judge of Appeal Nicholls forming the majority that rejected it. The court also ordered him to pay costs.

During the proceedings, details emerged about how police officers came across the body.

The court heard that Warrant Officers Allen Mark Naidu and Sunil Seosunker were conducting crime-prevention patrols in Durban’s Point area when they encountered Okoro near Evaleigh Court.

Naidu told the court that Okoro hurried into the building after noticing their police vehicle, prompting the officers to follow him.

He later saw the Nigerian leave room 7 in an agitated condition while repeatedly calling out the name Francine.

Okoro then invited the officers into the apartment, where they found a man hanging from a bedsheet in the shower.

The officers reportedly became suspicious after observing the condition and position of the deceased, believing the scene might have been arranged to disguise a killing.

The court also examined whether the police had acted improperly in the handling of the case.

However, it found no evidence that officers deliberately misled prosecutors or withheld important information to prolong Okoro’s detention.

The judges consequently ruled that there was no legal basis to hold the Minister of Police responsible for keeping him in custody after his first court appearance.

DetentionNigerianSouth Africa